Home vs Investment Calculator

Compare buying, renting, or selling your home

🏠

Your Home Purchase

Details about when you bought your home
Typically 10-20% of home price
Usually 15 or 30 years
Principal + Interest only
Tax + Insurance + HOA + Maintenance
Leave 0 for estimated appreciation
📈

Alternative: Rent & Invest

What if you had rented and invested instead?
What rent was when you bought
Typical: 2-5% per year
S&P 500 historical: ~10%
Historical average: 3-5%
💡 How it works: We'll calculate what your down payment + monthly savings would be worth if invested in the stock market instead of buying a home.
Years Since Purchase: 4 years
Total Housing Cost (Buy): $126,504
Total Housing Cost (Rent): $89,424
🏠

Your Current Home

Details about the house you own now
Mortgage + taxes + insurance + HOA + maintenance
Historical average: 3-5% per year
🔑

If You Sell & Rent

Your situation after selling the home
Realtor fees + closing costs + repairs
What you'd pay to rent a similar place
Typical: 2-5% per year
S&P 500 historical: ~10%
Estimated Sale Proceeds: $180,000
Monthly Savings (Keep vs Rent): $1,000/mo

If You Bought The House

$0
Total net worth from home ownership

If You Rented & Invested

$0
Total investment portfolio value

Total Paid for Housing (Home)

$0
EMI + Additional costs over time

Total Paid for Housing (Rent)

$0
Rent + Renter's insurance over time

Net Worth Over Time

Monthly Housing Costs Comparison

Cumulative Spending vs Asset Growth

Detailed Breakdown

🏠 Home Ownership

Down Payment $0
Total EMI Paid $0
Total Interest Paid $0
Principal Paid $0
Additional Costs $0
Current Home Value $0
Home Equity $0
Remaining Mortgage $0
NET WORTH (Home) $0

📈 Rent & Invest

Down Payment Invested $0
Total Rent Paid $0
Renter's Insurance Paid $0
Monthly Savings Invested $0
Investment Gains $0
Portfolio Value $0
NET WORTH (Invest) $0

⚠️ Assumptions & Notes

  • Investment returns are compounded monthly
  • Rent increases annually at the specified rate
  • Home appreciation is calculated annually
  • Does not account for tax benefits of mortgage interest
  • Does not include closing costs or selling costs
  • Investment returns are before taxes
  • Past performance doesn't guarantee future results
  • Maintenance costs can vary significantly

Generating your PDF report...

📋 What This Means For You

🏠 Keep House

$0
per month
VS

💰 Sell & Rent

$0
per month (Year 1)
You'd save $0/mo by selling

⏱️ Break-Even Analysis

Now
Year 10
🏠 Keep House Leads 💰 Sell & Invest Leads

⚠️ Tax Consideration

If You Keep The House

$0
Projected equity in 10 years

If You Sell & Invest

$0
Projected portfolio in 10 years

Net Proceeds From Sale

$0
After paying mortgage & fees

Monthly Cash Flow Change

$0
Rent vs current home costs

Net Worth Projection: Keep vs Sell

Monthly Housing Costs Over Time

🎯 What If Scenarios

How would different market conditions affect your decision?

📊 Year-by-Year Breakdown

Year Home Equity Portfolio Value Difference Better Option

Detailed Projection Breakdown

🏠 Keep The House

Current Home Value $0
Projected Home Value $0
Total Housing Costs $0
Principal Paid Down $0
Remaining Mortgage $0
NET WORTH (Keep) $0

💰 Sell & Invest

Sale Price (after costs) $0
Initial Investment $0
Total Rent Paid $0
Monthly Savings Invested $0
Investment Gains $0
NET WORTH (Sell) $0

⚠️ Assumptions & Notes

  • Capital gains tax on home sale not included (may apply if gains > $250k/$500k)
  • Investment returns are before taxes
  • Rent increases annually at the specified rate
  • Home appreciation is calculated annually
  • Does not include moving costs
  • Assumes you can invest the full proceeds

✅ If You Decide to Sell - Next Steps

  1. Get a professional home valuation Get 2-3 real estate agents to give you a CMA (Comparative Market Analysis)
  2. Calculate your actual equity Request a mortgage payoff statement from your lender
  3. Understand tax implications Consult a tax professional about capital gains exclusion ($250k single / $500k married)
  4. Research rental options Find comparable rentals in your desired area to confirm rent estimates
  5. Open investment accounts Set up brokerage account (Fidelity, Vanguard, Schwab) before closing
  6. Keep 6-month emergency fund Don't invest ALL proceeds - keep 6 months of expenses in savings
  7. Consider dollar-cost averaging Instead of investing all at once, spread it over 6-12 months to reduce timing risk